The hidden divide at the heart of the GOP's immigration fight
Is our current immigration system like free trade — or corporate welfare?
With a few words to Glenn Beck last week, Scott Walker busted open the conservative debate on immigration.
The Wisconsin governor and possible presidential candidate called for a "legal immigration system that's based, first and foremost, on protecting American workers and American wages." His remarks were widely circulated by Breitbart's doggedly anti-amnesty reporter Matthew Boyle. Then the internet exploded, with some of the strongest negative reactions coming from my fellow conservatives.
Note that Walker, whose position on whether he would offer legal status to illegal immigrants is famously murky, stops short of actually calling for a lower level of legal immigration. But he does invoke Alabama Sen. Jeff Sessions, the most prominent Republican who is calling for curbing immigration.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
The political ramifications of Walker's comments are unclear. He appeared to cut against things he's said about immigration in the past, and certainly contradicted the preferences of major Republican donors, including the otherwise Walker-friendly Koch brothers. But Walker's concern about immigration and wages comes as polls for the first time show him losing his grip on conservatives to candidates who are theoretically vulnerable on immigration.
The contours of the conservative debate on immigration are relatively clear. To conservatives who disagree with the sentiments Walker expressed, our current immigration policy is like free trade. Lowering immigration levels to protect American wages is like protectionism, they argue. If anything, they say, our immigration caps are already too low and account for why there is so much illegal immigration.
Plenty of conservatives who agree with Walker and Sessions don't care much for free trade either. But many of us who aren't trade protectionists nevertheless think the trade/immigration analogy is flawed. People are different than goods, even if labor is a commodity. An employer gets an immigrant's labor, but America gets the whole person.
Immigration is not just about economics. It involves citizenship, a membership in the American nation-state based on criteria defined by the broader political community. When there is no citizenship, as is the case with various guest-worker programs, you get laborers who are heavily dependent on their employers and effectively denied membership in the political community.
"One of the worst things about illegal immigration is that it creates a class of people who contribute their labor to this country but aren't full participants in it and lack the rights and responsibilities of everyone else," writes Ramesh Ponnuru. "A guest-worker program doesn't solve this problem. It formalizes it."
Plus, a lot of people who cite market forces in their conservative immigration arguments are missing the bigger picture. As David Frum notes in The Atlantic, we seldom hear the following immigration scenarios:
And yet, these same theories are deployed in defense of immigration — because it enhances labor competition at the middle and lower rungs of the economic ladder.
Maybe our immigration policy is less like free trade than corporate welfare. Dave Brat made this argument en route to defeating Eric Cantor, the sitting House majority leader, in a Republican primary last year. And it's not hard to see why this view is appealing to conservatives.
Immigration's impact on American jobs and wages is hotly contested. But the arguments Walker is starting to entertain are at least as plausible as Jeb Bush's plan to have immigrant workers finance the baby boomers' retirement. This is a debate conservatives need to have. Is immigration like free trade, corporate welfare — or something much bigger than either?
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
W. James Antle III is the politics editor of the Washington Examiner, the former editor of The American Conservative, and author of Devouring Freedom: Can Big Government Ever Be Stopped?.
-
'Biden is smart to keep the border-security pressure on'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
Bird flu worries mount as virus found in milk, cows
Speed Read The FDA found traces of the virus in pasteurized grocery store milk
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
Palazzo Durazzo Suites in Genoa: a palatial gem in northern Italy
The Week Recommends Live your Italian dream in this astonishing and recently restored palace in the heart of the city
By Nick Hendry Published
-
Arizona court reinstates 1864 abortion ban
Speed Read The law makes all abortions illegal in the state except to save the mother's life
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US Published
-
Trump, billions richer, is selling Bibles
Speed Read The former president is hawking a $60 "God Bless the USA Bible"
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
The debate about Biden's age and mental fitness
In Depth Some critics argue Biden is too old to run again. Does the argument have merit?
By Grayson Quay Published
-
How would a second Trump presidency affect Britain?
Today's Big Question Re-election of Republican frontrunner could threaten UK security, warns former head of secret service
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
'Rwanda plan is less a deterrent and more a bluff'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By The Week UK Published
-
Henry Kissinger dies aged 100: a complicated legacy?
Talking Point Top US diplomat and Nobel Peace Prize winner remembered as both foreign policy genius and war criminal
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Last updated
-
Trump’s rhetoric: a shift to 'straight-up Nazi talk'
Why everyone's talking about Would-be president's sinister language is backed by an incendiary policy agenda, say commentators
By The Week UK Published
-
More covfefe: is the world ready for a second Donald Trump presidency?
Today's Big Question Republican's re-election would be a 'nightmare' scenario for Europe, Ukraine and the West
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published