he rapper Wyclef Jean's attempts to raise money for earthquake-stricken victims in his native Haiti have run into trouble. The Haitian-American musician has raised over $1 million since the disaster for his charitable organisation Yele Haiti, but some are questioning the legitimacy of Yele Haiti, with allegations of financial misconduct including a payment made to Jean himself for a charity concert. Jean responded to critics on YouTube by calling the criticism of his charity's expenses "disgusting." Is Yele Hait a scam, or is it being unfairly criticized at the worst possible time? (Watch Wyclef Jean defend Yele Haiti)
Many charities are badly organized -- not all help as much as Yele Haiti: Yele Haiti's "mismanagement" started when Haiti "was a disaster no-one cared about," says Tim Cavanaugh at Reason.com, so it's a stretch to imagine it will "rise to the occasion" now. But let's not forget "non-profit management" is an "ugly business." Even "major charities" spend donations on "waste, rent-seeking, [and] politicking." Wyclef Jean is probably doing more for Haiti than most people.
"Yele Haiti: Ready Or Not?"
It's too small to make a difference: Wyclef Jean clearly has a "long-standing commitment" to the people of Haiti, says John Cook at Gawker. But his charity "is not the best place for your money to go right now." Allegations of financial impropriety aside, Yele Haiti is a "tiny operation" with only one employee, and it is "at risk of being overwhelmed with donations." Emergency money is best given to "one of the larger NGOs" -- not a "small player" like Yele Haiti.
"More on Why Donating to Wyclef Jean's Charity Might Not Be the Best Way to Help Haitians Right Now"
But giving to Haiti may not help anyway: Raising cash for Haitians -- as Yele Haiti is attempting to do -- is "not necessarily a good thing", says Felix Salmon at Reuters. "Throwing money" at "failed states" like Haiti is "very likely to backfire". A far better way to help would be to make an "unrestricted donation" to an aid group such as Doctors Without Borders, which has already received enough in donations to keep its Haiti operations running "for the best part of the next decade," but could use unrestricted donations to help it respond to "equally tragic situations around the world."
"Don't give money to Haiti"
THE WEEK'S AUDIOPHILE PODCASTS: LISTEN SMARTER
- Who are the real gay marriage bigots?
- What the collapse of the Ming Dynasty can tell us about American decline
- What would a U.S.-Russia war look like?
- Watch The Daily Show mock Fox News' confused man-crush on Vladimir Putin
- Religious liberty should be a liberal value, too
- Why is American internet so slow?
- 22 TV shows to watch in 2014
- The new bride who had a horrifying allergic reaction to her husband's sperm
- Don't worry: World War III will almost certainly never happen
- Is the Republican Party in danger of dying out?
Subscribe to the Week