Before Carrie Prejean: 7 disgraced beauty queens

Carrie Prejean's sex tape scandal is just the latest chapter in America's long history of fallen pageant winners

Thursday, November 12, 2009
Before Carrie Prejean: 7 disgraced beauty queens

Carrie Prejean is just the latest in a long line of scandal-prone beauty queens.
(Reuters/Corbis/Steve Marcus)

Best sources: PBS, Fox News, NY Times, NY Daily News

Former Miss California Carrie Prejean has admitted making a sex tape for a boyfriend as a teenager and is describing the episode as "the biggest mistake of my life." But she's hardly the first beauty queen to endure public embarrassment. Here are several of her more notable predecessors:

Vanessa Williams 
In 1983, Williams became the first black winner of the Miss America pageant. Ten months later she was pressured to resign her crown when Penthouse magazine published nude photos of her posing with another woman. Williams says that the pictures were innocent--that she was merely helping a photographer she worked for conceptualize a shoot--and that they were never meant to be made public. She initially filed a lawsuit against Penthouse publisher Bob Guccione, but later dropped the case to focus on her music career. She has subsequently enjoyed great success as both a singer and actress.

Katie Rees
After being named Miss Nevada USA in 2006, Rees lost her title when photos emerged of her flashing her breasts and her thong underwear and kissing other young women in a nightclub. Last year, she was arrested for assaulting a cop after a traffic stop and subsequently detained in Australia on suspicion of drug trafficking (no charges were filed).

Lindsay Evans
The 2008 winner of Miss Louisiana Teen USA pageant became a household name when she skipped out on a restaurant bill and left behind her purse containing a small bag of marijuana. When she returned to retrieve the purse, she was arrested for both theft and drug possession.  She lost her title ten days before the end of her reign.

Marjorie Wallace
The first American ever to win the Miss World pageant quickly became a tabloid celebrity linked to various famous men including married Welsh crooner Tom Jones and British soccer star George Best. According to the New York Times, she resigned her crown after Best was charged with burglarizing her home. She went on to enjoy later success as a talkshow host.

Tara Conner
Although Tara Conner, Miss USA 2006, was one of the worst-behaved pageant queens, she was not stripped of her title thanks to the support of business mogul (and owner of the Miss USA franchise) Donald Trump. Days after newspaper reports that the party girl had tested positive for cocaine, Trump announced Conner was going to rehab, but would keep her title.

Lauren Caitlin Upton
The 18-year-old Upton, representing South Carolina in the Miss Teen USA 2007 competition, became an overnight internet sensation for her incoherent, rambling response to a question about why so many Americans can’t locate their own country on a map. She replied: "I personally believe that U.S. Americans are unable to do so because, uh, some people out there in our nation don't have maps and, uh, I believe that our, uh, education like such as in, uh, South Africa and, uh, the Iraq and everywhere like such as, and I believe that they should, uh, our education over here in the U.S. should help the U.S., uh, should help South Africa and should help Iraq and the Asian countries, so we will be able to build up our future for our children."
(Watch Lauren Caitlin Upton give her timeless response about Americans and maps)

Amy Polumbo
Miss New Jersey 2007 pre-empted greater scandal when she announced that would-be blackmailers were threatening to release old photos from her Facebook page if she refused to relinquish her title. Polumbo later released photos of herself drinking and partying.  "They're not that bad, but they were meant to be private," Polumbo said.

Show: Oldest | Newest

18 Comments

Posted by bill, Friday, November 13, 2009, 2:22 pm What about Vanessa Williams?

Posted by Fred, Friday, November 13, 2009, 3:05 pm Bill, did you read the article?

Posted by Mary, Friday, November 13, 2009, 3:07 pm If Carrie Prejean had bowed down and kissed fag ass, then she would still be the darling of the media. You know it.

Posted by Craig, Friday, November 13, 2009, 3:11 pm It's the disgraced ones that become superstars, go figure

Posted by jarrod, Friday, November 13, 2009, 3:38 pm Dont forget Anita Bryant the anti gay Florida Orange Juice Queen. She has paid a very high price two bankruptcies, divorce and loss of job.

Posted by MS38654OB, Friday, November 13, 2009, 3:51 pm The only one on the list with any class is Vanessa Williams, the rest are dumb as rocks and/or just plain trash.

Posted by gimpydwarf, Friday, November 13, 2009, 3:52 pm Mary: you are an Idiot.Bill: read the freakin' article.Since when is it disgraceful to have a life, to drink, To have fun, to kiss people and for beautiful woman to pose nude? This is normal life.And why do we even have an expectation of these beauty queens being smart?Get real. Get a life. Quit judging.

Posted by proud_elitest, Friday, November 13, 2009, 7:54 pm yes gimpydwarf Mary is a gomer, about as bright as the freakshow Prejean was in her interview can you spell HYPOCRITICAL? try:CHRISTIAN or RIGHTWINGER or REPUBLICAN hypocrits ALL!!!! Arrogant, smarmy, smug, selfrighteous doofuses who can't read and gloat in their ignorance.Go ahead, throw your teabagging parties gay snicker!!! lol the connotation is HILARIOUS!!! Clueless IDIOTS!!!.

Post a Comment

February 12, 2010

Newsletter

Sign up here for our daily newsletter

Privacy Policy | Sample Newsletter